Let’s say you own a restaurant and you’ve narrowed your payroll search to two companies. One quote has a lower monthly price, a few free months, and a package that includes HR advice and employee training. You’re already wondering why you’d pay more for the other one.

Then you go through the quotes with your bookkeeper. The lower price doesn’t include the connection to your timekeeping software, and year-end payroll forms cost extra. The other quote includes both. Meanwhile, you already have someone you trust for HR advice, and you have no plans to use the training courses.

The first offer might still be a good deal. But you’ll need to add up a full year of the services you need before you can tell. Those unused extras won’t help pay the difference.

Which services will you actually use?

A deal on an all-you-can-eat buffet sounds great if you’re planning to sit down for dinner. If you’re looking for takeout on the way home, unlimited trips to the buffet don’t do much for you. You need a meal you can take with you.

Payroll packages deserve the same thought. Extra services only add value when you’ll use them. Think about the help you need now and over the coming year, so you can tell whether the package fits your business before its price wins you over.

Pay cards, for example, let employees receive their pay on a prepaid card instead of in a bank account. If you expect to offer them, you’ll want to understand the service and its cost. If you don’t, including them in a package gives you little reason to pay more for it.

The same goes for services you might need later. Help with Affordable Care Act (ACA) reporting could matter to your business, but that’s something to establish with your accountant or benefits adviser before paying for it. A package shouldn’t get credit for solving a problem you don’t have.

You can leave room for growth without paying for a future you haven’t reached. If you expect to hire in another state or bring time tracking into payroll, include that in the comparison. For everything else, find out whether you can add it when you need it and what that would cost. That lets you judge whether moving up a tier now is worth it.

Are you comparing apples to apples?

Before deciding one provider costs less, make sure both quotes cover the same payroll needs. A lower total may simply mean one company left out a service you need or used a different headcount. Give each provider the same details about your employees, pay schedule, states, and services, and check that the written quote reflects them.

Say you have 25 employees and pay them every other week, but one quote assumes 20 employees paid twice a month. Have that provider correct the quote before comparing the totals. If there’s a fee for each employee, also ask how employees are counted for billing and have the provider price your workforce using that definition.

Ask how faster direct deposit is priced, too. Is next-day turnaround included in the quoted fee, part of a particular package, or something you pay for each time you use it? If your business often needs that shorter gap between approving payroll and payday, add the per-use fees to your annual estimate. Then compare that total with the annual price of a package that includes it. Confirm that your business qualifies for the timing you’re being quoted, too.

The monthly price isn’t the whole story

A low monthly price can lose its appeal when quarterly charges and a year-end bill arrive. Comparing a full year of service fees helps you see that before you sign, even when the providers charge in different ways.

Ask each provider to spell out every recurring charge you should expect, including any monthly fees, charges for each payroll, quarterly filing fees, and year-end fees. Add them up using the number of months, payrolls, or filings you’ll actually pay for.

Ask specifically whether W-2 preparation and filing are included. If they cost extra, have the provider show how the charge is calculated and include it in the annual total.

There may also be extra fees that don’t appear on the quote. Ask for the full fee schedule so you can see what an added service, a one-time request, or an extra payroll run could cost. If you occasionally run a separate payroll to pay a departing employee, include the runs you reasonably expect. Keep less likely charges in your notes so you know about them without counting them as regular expenses.

If you have paper checks or payroll reports delivered to your office, find out what delivery costs and how often you’ll pay for it. If you need payroll connected to your timekeeping or accounting software, ask whether that carries a separate charge too. Include any fees for those services in your annual estimate. Our payroll integrations article explains how to judge whether the connection will do what you need.

Could a bundle be a better deal?

Once you know which services you need, ask whether the provider offers a bundle that includes them. A lower-priced plan can become the more expensive choice once you add time tracking, faster direct deposit, and year-end forms.

Compare the total for the smaller plan with the price of the bundle. If the bundle costs less for the services you need, it may be the better choice even if some extras go unused. If it costs more, those extras need to be useful enough to justify the difference. A longer feature list won’t do that for you.

What happens when the introductory price ends?

A few free months can be a welcome saving, especially when you’re also paying to switch. You’ll still want to know what a normal year will cost once that offer is over. Put two totals beside each quote: the first year, with the actual discount and setup charges, and a full year at the price quoted after the promotion ends. Apply the discount only to the charges and months the offer covers.

Think back to the restaurant comparing two quotes. Free months could make the first plan cheaper in year one, even after paying for the timekeeping connection and year-end forms. Once the promotion ends, those extra charges remain. The other plan could then cost less. You won’t know until you add up both versions of the year.

The discount might end after a few months, a year, or some other period. Use the dates and terms in the offer. And ask separately how future price increases work; the price after a promotion isn’t necessarily a promise about every renewal.

Free doesn’t mean no cost

As a business owner, you know time is money. A provider can waive its setup fee, but it can’t give you back the time you spend making the switch. You or your bookkeeper will still need to gather records, answer questions, and help check the account before the first payroll. Employees may need new accounts or a new app to see their pay stubs.

Getting everyone onto a new system and answering their questions takes effort, particularly as your workforce grows. It’s worth weighing that effort now, including whether you’d be willing to go through it again if the price stops making sense after the promotion.

A good price won’t make up for a bad fit

Suppose you’re ready to approve payroll and something doesn’t look right. You want a knowledgeable person to call, but the less expensive service offers only help articles. You may still be able to work it out yourself. The question is whether that’s how you wanted to spend your time when you chose the service.

The work you keep belongs in the comparison too. Entering changes, chasing answers, or fixing records may fall to you or your bookkeeper. Deciding how much of payroll you want to handle yourself helps you judge whether the difference in price is worth it.

Before signing, get the pricing and fee schedule in writing and check the agreement. Is it month to month, or are you committing for longer? How can the price change, how much notice would you get, and what would leaving early cost? Those answers matter if the service or the bill turns out to be different from what you expected.

Have the provider confirm any missing prices in writing, too. A blank on the quote doesn’t mean a service is free. Once you can compare the full annual bills, you can judge whether paying more would buy you help you want or leave you paying for extras you won’t use.

Sources